| A Global Forum for Naval
Historical Scholarship |
International Journal of Naval History |
| Home Mission & Structure Editorial Board Archives Submissions Letters Site Map |
| Previous
Page PDF
HMS
Suva, Captain W.H.D. Boyle and the The
Strategic Effects of an Auxiliary Cruiser upon the Arab Revolt Gregory P. Gilbert RAN
Sea Power Centre, Captain
William Boyle and the Political Naval Officer The
career of Captain William Boyle, later Admiral of the Fleet and Earl of From
an early age, William Boyle was treated as one of the select few of the
British aristocracy who could be groomed by the Royal Navy for senior
political appointments. His early service emphasised the basic sea
duties of the times, including pulling and sailing boat experience, but
also included extensive experience overseas where Boyle began to
understand other cultures. Before being promoted to Commander, Boyle
spent nine years in the Pacific, either with the But
Boyle was determined to leave his comparative idleness in
1. security of 2. projection of maritime power in the Red Sea littoral in support of the Arab Revolt, as a means to wear down Turkish military forces, and 3. promotion of Unfortunately,
the longer term political effects of the policy to support the Arab
Revolt, and the consequent division of the Ottoman Empire, were not
foreseen by these commanders, or if they did predict the disintegration
of the Of
course, Captain Boyle's career did not end in 1917. He was fortunate,
and some would say well-connected enough, to hold a number of senior
commands and diplomatic appointments during the interwar years. At the
height of the Great Depression he was retained as President of the The In
early 1916, the Red Sea Patrol consisted of two old cruisers, four Royal
Indian Marine ships, two sloops, six armed boarding steamers, an armed
tug and a l The
first action occurred on 21 March 1916, when Fox
and On
6 June 1916 Sharif Hussein's irregular Arab forces attacked the Turkish
garrisons at The
campaign now turned the Asir region, south of Lith, and its principal After
their initial victories, British efforts were centred upon the creation
and maintenance of a strong Arab military force. The irregular Arab
forces were reinforced with Arab troops recruited from Turkish prisoners
in During
October 1916, Turkish forces under Fakri Pasha advanced against the Arab
forces and pushed Prince Ali back to Rabugh and his brother Prince
Feisal back to Yembo. Consideration was given to sending a British Army
brigade to defend Rabugh, but was ultimately rejected, largely due to
the sensitivities of landing a large body of British troops in what was
Islamic Holy territory.[xxii]
Once again, the Red Sea Patrol and Egyptian troops, held back the Turks.
A flight of planes from the Royal Flying Corps helped to defend Rabugh,
while aircraft from the seaplane carrier Anne
assisted in the defence of Yembo. In addition, Prince Abdullah, another
of Sharif Hussein's sons, led a successful raid on the Hejaz railway,
which alarmed Fakri Pasha sufficiently to convince him to withdraw the
Turkish forces back towards The
role of the Red Sea Patrol remained politically sensitive. In late 1916,
Captain Boyle's ships were used to convey the Holy Carpet (presented
annually from Working with the irregular Arab forces was not easy, and at times the British found that their Allies were more dangerous than the Turks. T.E. Lawrence describes one such incident. 'There was a fight three days ago between 300 Ageyl and 400 Hadheyl over a question of camels. About 1000 rounds were fired, and two men were killed and six wounded. The fight was checked by Feisal himself, who went out bare-headed and bare-footed, as he happened to be and made peace at once. Some bullets struck the Monitor (M.31) in the harbour, and narrowly missed wounding or killing some of her crew. Sharif Feisal came off, when the matter was pointed out to him by Captain Boyle, and expressed his regret.'[xxiv] A
manoeuvre to the northern coastal town of The
capture of Akaba secured the northern One
of the difficulties with operations in the Lessons
Learnt from a Side-Show Although
the Red Sea Patrol, which included HMS Suva, operated in a
theatre that has frequently been called a side-show, there are a number
of lessons that can be learnt from her experiences. Between 1916-1918
the British were able to project power ashore in the Sea
power not only supported the Arab Revolt with gold, arms and supplies,
but the very presence of Royal Navy ships helped sustain the political
will of those leading the Arab Revolt against the Turks. In many ways
the effects of Boyle's Red Sea Squadron exceeded the expectations of
those responsible for the strategic direction of the war. The subsequent
disintegration of the Acknowledgements I wish to thank the Royal
Australian Navy's Sea Power Centre - Picture
Credits The image of HMS Suva is from
the Imperial http://www.telstudies.org.uk/telstudies_org_uk/legacy1/gallery/photos/1914-18/r107.htm _________________________________________________________ Appendix A: Chronology of HMS Suva's
War Service 1915-1918 (Related principal events are in bold.)[xxx] 1914 29 October
- Ottoman Empire enters war against 1-8 November
- British bombardment of Akaba. 14 November
- Turkish Sultan declares Islamic holy war against 1915 3-11 February
- Turkish attack on the 19
July
- HMS Suva
requisitioned by the Admiralty at Aug/Sep
- On transit to Oct/Nov
- Refitting at December
- Steams via 1916 5
January
- Commenced first patrol in northern
From 1916 until 1918
using 21 March - Bombardment of Wejh Fort. 5-6 April - Operations at Akaba. 19-20 May - Seizure of Dhow off Lith. 5 June
- Sharif of 9-10 June
- Jiddah and 8 July - Bombardment of Qunfundah and prisoners taken. 28 & 30 July - Bombardment of Qunfundah. 1-3 August - Maxim parties ashore at Qunfundah. 22 August - Fire in cold storage room put out. September - Seizure of Dhows. 22 September
- Ta'if captured by Arab forces. 5 October - Seizure of Dhow off Berbera. 17
October -
Captain W.H.D. Boyle, RN takes command of 1-4 November - Patrol from Rabugh, via Yembo to Jiddah, including Commander in Chief's inspection and passage by T.E. Lawrence. 10-11
November -
Transported troops from 22-24 December - Transported Egyptian troops from Yembo to Rabugh. 1917 10-11 January - Transported Arab troops from Yembo to Umm Lejh. 20
January
- Captain Boyle transfers command and leaves 24-25 January - Occupation of Wejh. 31
January -
Departs February
to May -
Refitting at June/July - Returns to Red Sea Patrol, operating in southern area. June - Occupation of Salif. June
- Bombardment of 6 July
- Akaba captured by Arab forces. 2-8
September
- Captain Boyle embarked from 19-22
September -
Transported troops from 22-26 September - Transported Arab troops from Akaba to Jiddah. 27-29 September - Ship grounded on shoal off Jiddah and refloated. 30
September
- Transported troops from - 1 October 27-31 October
- General Allenby defeats Turks at 27-28 October - Took HMS Pyramus in tow. 30-31 October - Transported Arab troops from Yembo to Jiddah. 2-5 November - Transported Arab troops from Yembo to Akaba. 8-26
November -
Refitting at 30
November - Depart with
troops from 2-3 December - Disembark Egyptian troops at Wejh and French troops at Yembo. 1918 January-March - On Perim Patrol. 19 January - Fire in bunker extinguished. 10 February - Perim bombardment and dhow actions. April/May
- Refitting at 4
June
- Arrived at 12-13 June - Bombardment of Loheiya. 17-20 June - Bombardment of Loheiya. 20-21 August - SS Cardian in tow. 14 September - Bombardment of Qunfundah. 19 September - Bombardment of Loheiya. 23 September - Shop grounded off Kamaran. October/November - On Perim patrol. 11 November
- Armistice day. 13-20
December -
Bombardment of
(bec Appendix
B: Summary of HMS Suva Ship's
Log Qunfundah Operations - 8 July,
& 28 July to 3 August 1916 8 July 1916
The Surrender of Qunfundah 0000-0015 Searchlight
shown on town and trenches. 0200-0215 Searchlight
shown on town and trenches. 0400-0415 Searchlight shown on town and trenches. 0945 Action Stations. 1011 Warning gun fired by HMS Fox [a second class cruiser]. 1014 Commenced bombardment of town. 1040 Ceased firing. 1049 HMS Fox hoisted White Flag as symbol. 1050 Man observed, with White Flag, to leave town and approach beach. 1400 Secured guns. 1640 Lowered lifeboats and whaler. 1717 Steam cutter with Maxim and armed party proceed to pier with lifeboats and whaler in tow to bring off Turkish prisoners. 1832 Idrissi flag hoisted at Qunfundah. 1850 Prisoners embarking. 2030 Last batch of prisoners embarked, hoisted whaler and life boats. Number of prisoners - 10 officers, 190 other ranks, and 2 children. Ammunition and rifles taken from prisoners dispatched to HMS Fox. Received one Petty Officer and twelve others from Fox as armed guard. Despite the surrender of the
Turkish garrison on 8 July 1916, elements of the Arab population did not
support the pro-British Idrissi leadership at Qunfundah. 28 July 1916
At Qunfundah 0100 Fired one round of common shell from port foremost gun, over town. 0300-0320 Searchlight
shown on town. 1040 Captain and party of officers left ship and proceeded to land to visit town. 1310 Captain and officers returned to ship. 2030 Steam cutter proceeded to shore for Sheikh and guard. 2230 Sheikh returned to shore. 2300 Fired one round of common shell over town, searchlight shown on town. 29 July 1916
At Qunfundah 0200-0220 Searchlight
shown on town. 1030 Party of officers left ship to visit town. 1325 Officers party returned to ship. 1800-1900 [Ship proceeds to new position off reef SSE of Island] 2035 Steam cutter with whaler in tow proceeded to shore. 2100-2120 Searchlight shown on town. 2245 Steam cutter + whaler returns to ship. 2305-2320 Searchlight shown on town and surroundings. 30 July 1916
At Qunfundah 0015 Fired one round of common shell behind town. 0200-0220 Searchlight
shown on shore and to rear of town. 1030 Held Divine Service. 1100-1127 [Ship proceeds to new anchorage SE of Island] 1715 Fired one round common shell from after gun, behind town. 1721 Fired second round from after gun. 2100 Fired one round common shell over town. 2217 Action stations. Fired two rounds common shell over town, searchlight shown on town. 1 August 1916
At Qunfundah 0400 Fired one 4.7 blank charge. 0405
Maxim parties left ship in steam cutter and whaler to take up
station
close in shore. 0735 Maxim parties returned to ship. 0930 Sheik + party arrived on board. 1000 Exercised landing party. 1030 Fired one blank charge No. 1 Gun and 150 rounds with Maxim. 1100 Landing party dispersed. 1140 Steam cutter and whaler proceed to shore with Sheikh. 1200 Fired one blank charge. 1520 Large dhow arrived + anchored. 1850 Fired one blank charge from after gun. 1920 Exercised night firing at target. 2030 Fired one common from after gun. 2 August 1916
At Qunfundah Night Searchlight shown every half hour for 10 mins throughout the night. 0405
Steam cutter and whaler left ship with two Maxim parties to take
up
station close in shore. 0700 Maxim Parties returned. 2025 Fired one round common shell. 3 August 1916
At Qunfundah Night Searchlight shown to the right of town for 10 mins every half hour. 0330
Steam cutter and whaler left ship and proceeded close in shore
with two Maxim
parties. 0725 Maxim parties returned to ship. 0940 Sheikh and party from town arrived on board to visit ship. Fired 150 rounds from Maxim fitted in steam cutter. 1145 Sheikh and party left ship. HMS Lunka arrived and anchored. Received 4 bags of mail from Lunka. 1300 Hands to make and mend clothes. 1400 Received one packing case containing pump from Lunka. 2100 Dispatched to HMS Lunka 2 bags mail 1 packet letters. Appendix C: Short Biography of Admiral of the Fleet, the 12th
Earl of William Henry Dudley Boyle, RN, GCB,
KCB, CB, GCVO, (1873-1967) 1887 Entered the Royal Navy as Naval Cadet on Britannia. 1888-1894 Served
on Monarch, 1894 Commissioned as Sub-Lieutenant.
Served on the
gunboat Crescent in the 1895 Promoted to Lieutenant. 1895-1897 Served
on the gunboat Lizard in the
Including anti-'Blackbirding'
patrols in the South West Pacific and
patrols to 1898 Served with the Channel Fleet on the cruiser Furious. 1898-1901 Served
in command of the sloop Daphne in the Participated during the Boxer Rebellion. 1902 Married Lady Florence Keppel. 1902-1904 Commanded
the destroyer Haughty in 1904
Served as First Lieutenant (Gunnery) on the cruiser Astraea
in the 1905-1906 Commanded
Astraea in the 1906 Promoted to Commander. 1906-1908 Commanded the battleship Hiberia in the Channel Fleet. 1909-1911 Served with the Naval Intelligence Department of the Admiralty. 1911-1912 Commanded the armoured cruiser Good Hope, in the Atlantic Fleet. 1912 Commanded the destroyer Skirmisher with the Dover Patrol. 1913-1915 Appointed
Naval Attaché in 1913 Promoted to Captain. 1913 Observer during the second Balkan War. Feb-Apr
1915
Attached to Rear Admiral R.E. Wemyss' staff off Gallipoli,
(although unofficially absent from Oct
1915
Commanding the second class cruiser Fox
in the Dec 1915 Appointed Senior Officer Red Sea Patrol. Oct
1916- Jan 1917 Commanding Nov
1917
Left the 1917-1919 Commanded the battle cruiser Repulse. 1922-1923 Naval ADC to the King. 1923 Promoted Rear Admiral. 1923-1925 Commanded
2nd 1926-1928 Commanded
1st Cruiser Squadron on the 1928 Promoted Vice Admiral. 1929-1933 President
of the Royal Naval College, 1932 Promoted Admiral. 1933-1935 Commander in Chief, Home Fleet. 1934 Succeeded cousin as 12th Earl of Cork and Orrery. 1936-1937 First and Principal ADC to the King. 1937-1939 Commander
in Chief, 1938 Promoted Admiral of the Fleet (retires 1941) 1940
Commanded Combined Expedition in 1941-1942 Lieutenant Colonel with the Home Guard. [i] Arthur W. Jose, The Royal Australian Navy, Official History of Australia in the War 1914-1918, Volume IX, Angus and Robinson, Sydney, 1928, p. 494, see also pp. 238-239, 481 and 494-495. [ii]
The HMS Suva Logs
are retained in the United Kingdom (UK) National Archives, ADM
53/61865-61894. A summary of HMS Suva
activities may also be found on Log Extract Cards at the Royal
Navy's Historical Branch, [iii] Suva's groundings are somewhat understandable, given the Red Sea coast was essentially a coral formation with outlying reefs, with harbours mostly inlets between reefs that were only approachable at certain times of the day. Surveying was almost non-existent until 1917 and many of the buoys and beacons had been removed by the Turks in the early part of the war. 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval Review, Vol. 13, 1925, p. 652. [iv]
Captain William Boyle, RN was Senior Officer of the Red Sea
Patrol between December 1915 and November 1917. His career is
discussed elsewhere in this paper and his [v]
HMS Suva is
mentioned several times in Lieutenant Colonel Thomas E. Lawrence's
(Lawrence of Arabia) books, Seven
Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph, The Complete 1922 Edition, Castle
Hill, Fordingbridge, 1997; and the condensed version The
Arab Revolt, [vi] For the 'Holy Carpet' see Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, pp. 101-102. [vii] Here the terms 'high-end' and 'low-end' refer to positions on the spectrum of conflict that ranges from benign peace actions (low) to national wars of survival (high). [viii]
The proposed high/low mix of the future British sustained
surface combatant capability recognises three levels of required
capability, with the C3 general purpose corvette substituting for
the WWI [ix] Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, 1886-1941, p. 3. [x] Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, 1886-1941, p. 29. [xi] Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, 1886-1941, p. 92. [xii]
For the role of Admiral Wemyss during the Arab Revolt see
Lady Wester Wemyss, The Life
and Letters of Lord Wester Wemyss, Eyre and Spottiswoode, [xiii] For an overview of the Norway Campaign see Stephen W. Roskill, The War at Sea 1939-1945, Vol. 1, The Defensive, Her Majesty's Stationary Office, London, 1954, pp. 169-204; and Correlli Barnett, Engage the Enemy More Closely, Hodder & Stoughton, London, 1991, pp. 97-139. [xiv] Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, 1886-1941, p. 196. [xv]
The ships were Cruisers Fox,
Minerva; R.I.M. Ships Northbrook,
Dufferin, Hardinge, Minto; Armed
Boarding Steamers [xvi]
There are few accounts of the activities of the Red Sea
Patrol, although some material remains untouched in the UK National
Archives and the Royal Navy's Historical Branch. The main sources
for this paper are: 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval
Review, Vol. 13, 1925, pp. 648-667; and 'Naval Operations in the
Red Sea, 1917-18', Naval
Review, Vol. 14, 1926, pp. 48-56, both of which were probably
written by Captain Doyle as his [xvii] 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval Review, Vol. 13, 1925, pp. 653-654. [xviii]
Although Sharif Hussein's support was mostly localised in the
[xix] The important contribution made by naval aviation during the Arab Revolt is mentioned in R.D. Layman, Naval Aviation in the First World War: Its Impact and Influence, Chatham, 1996, pp. 153-155. Detailed accounts may be found in Henry A. Jones, The War in the Air, Vol. 5, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1935, pp. 218-224; and Cecil E. Hughes, Above and Beyond Palestine. An Account of the Work of the East Indies and Egypt Sea Plane Squadron 1916-1918, Ernest Benn, London, 1930. [xx]
The Turkish force in [xxi] General Reginald Wingate arrived with his staff to command the Hejaz Force on 4 October 1916. Of much less importance, Captain T.E. Lawrence did not arrive in Rabugh until 19 October. [xxii]
The region south of Wejh is considered Islamic 'Holy
territory into which no Christian prior to the war was allowed to
penetrate.' From 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval
Review, Vol. 13, 1925, p. 649. A small number of British
officers were admitted into the region, although even Lawrence of
Arabia was often mistakenly taken as a Syrian (due to his accent)
when operating in the [xxiii] 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval Review, Vol. 13, 1925, p. 658; see Earl of Cork & Orrery, My Naval Life, 1886-1941, p. 101. [xxiv]
From a letter from T.E. Lawrence at Yembo to Colonel C.E.
Wilson at Jiddah dated 19 December 1916 (Public Records Office
FO882/6) reprinted in Malcolm Brown, The
Letters of T.E. Lawrence, Oxford University Press, [xxv]
This reconstruction of the events surrounding the capture of
Akaba in 1917 is based upon that in James, The
Golden Warrior, The Life and Legend of [xxvi] 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval Review, Vol. 13, 1925, p. 662. [xxvii] The reader should consult 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1916-17', Naval Review, Vol. 13, 1925, pp. 662-667; and 'Naval Operations in the Red Sea, 1917-18', Naval Review, Vol. 14, 1926, pp. 48-56, for an overview of the Red Sea Patrol's activities from July 1917 until the end of the war. [xxviii] For the war against the Ottoman Empire and the Muslim contributions, see Hew Strachan, The First World War, Simon & Schuster, London, 2003, pp. 97-124, and 315-316. [xxix]
A number of decisions taken during WWI influenced the
development of the Middle East during
the 20th century and continue to resonate in the [xxx] Based upon official records. Note that some of the important dates listed vary with the sources used, hence I have used the most generally accepted.
|
||||
| Home Mission & Structure Editorial Board Archives Submissions Letters Site Map |
| The Editors International Journal of Naval History editors@ijnhonline.org © Copyright 2009, International Journal of Naval History, All Rights Reserved |
website design by Sunrise Designs, Inc. |